Where am I in the overall writing and editing process? Well…

Literature review is one of the crucial “milestones” in developing your research paper as this period gives you a full understanding of the scope and content of your research problem.

For me, literature review seems to be a “discourse” with other scholars on topic of my research. A discourse you are trying to have while looking through all those piles of articles related to your topic. My issue is the more “discourse” I have with scholars the more I get confused. Dozens of thoughts come to my mind while scrutinizing the ideas. You think about your contribution to an issue not duplicating someone’s work. It may sound cliché but I do not fancy discovering the continents again. I seek for a new and open problem, at least, aspect of the problem. Or, for example, how can I suggest promising solutions to the issue related to Kazakhstani context and many other questions.

What I am trying to do in this case is putting all those ideas into a system. After reading an article I completed a table with main research questions and findings of this article I read, which seemed a bit systematic. However, the most interesting stage of confusion came later on. At this stage I realized that merely a third share of all articles I read was relevant to my topic. Others were appropriate but not in such “close proximity” to my topic as I expected them to be after reading the title. So, titles can sometimes be misleading. Keywords and an abstract are helpful here though.

Another challenge I faced was being a distant student, not in terms of being an online-learner but in terms of a distance from Nazarbayev University Library. While on campus, I could easily access NU library login and download necessary articles, thanks to an extensive database of our library. However, from home, being 450 km from Astana, it appears to be impossible. What is more, the issue is not in access to database but in downloading articles. However, I am lucky enough to have very approachable group-mates who downloaded necessary articles and shared some with me. I am really grateful to them.

Where am I in the overall writing and editing process? Well, I am still in the process of searching and assessing articles in accordance with the relevance to my topic, ethical considerations and credibility of the sources.

I have a plan. I compiled a tentave must-read list of literature, half-of-read and half is not. First, I am going to read as much literature as I can to get acquainted with significant researchers in my field of reseacrh. It is amazing how one issue can be investigated and looked by many scholars from different perspectives. Once I critically studied and analysed all facets of my research question, I am going to start shaping my literature review.

I would just recommend those young researchers who do not know where to start their literature reviews from – just start reading.  Do not wait for the Eureka moment to happen thinking that all ideas will fall from the sky. Start your “discourse” with researchers.

And, what is your path in writing literature review? A smooth one or not without “bumps” on it? Can you share main difficulties you have with, and most importantly, what are your solutions to address those challenges?

Thank you

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Where am I in the overall writing and editing process? Well…

  1. Thank you Aliya for your wonderful post!

    I think that it will find a favourable attention of many students as you have provided valuable tips for writing literature review))) As you have mentioned here fulfilling the table might be very useful for systematizing the findings. So, I also attempt to use this method. I wish you good luck in writing your thesis!

    Like

  2. Dear Aliya,

    I really appreciate the experience you share about literature review.

    Personally, I also found challenging doing literature review, particularly when organising the reading in topics, subtopics, etc.

    As for the concerns you have in terms of “duplicating” already existing knowledge, it should not bother you since, as I believe, you are not searching for a research issue in the reading, instead, you are looking for ideas to add to your understanding of your research topic. As you will try to answer your research questions, no doubt, you will somehow contribute to the existing knowledge.

    Best regards,

    Gulnaz Zhukenova

    Like

  3. “I do not fancy discovering the continents again.” Your keen observation here is surely a shared sentiment among students at every level of schooling. It is great that you are so self-aware of what you are doing and why you have to do it, in terms of the search for knowledge and the original organization of these “piles of articles”.

    As for your difficulties in access to the library’s materials, have you contacted our subject librarian, or IT to help resolve these issues? As I understand, you should have no problem accessing materials, even off-campus.

    Finally, your writing is quite engaging and clear. I would only recommend that you pay attention to spell-checking (tentave) to make your writing perfect throughout.

    5/5

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s